Halloween gives us the perfect excuse to indulge in some guilty pleaseures. And while there’s nothing wrong with eating a fun-size Snickers straight from the bag, there’s a better way (in my opinion) to enjoy that Halloween candy: pair it with wine!
But before we start opening bottles, there’s an important question to ask:
Why do some pairings work better than others?
Wine pairing isn’t simply about matching flavors. Chocolate tastes like chocolate, so Cabernet is the answer, right? Not necessarily.
When pairing wine with food, we’re dealing with sweetness, acidity, bitterness, tannin, fat, salt, texture, and flavor intensity. These characteristics interact with one another and can actually change how we perceive the wine. Research has shown that appropriate pairings can alter the sensory characteristics of both the food and wine. So the goal isn’t just to find two things that taste good independently; it’s to find two things that make each other taste better.
And Halloween candy gives us some particularly interesting and challenging examples.
Snickers
This might be one of the easiest wine and candy pairings: Snickers and Sauternes.
Think about what’s in a Snickers bar. You’ve got milk chocolate, caramel, nougat, roasted peanuts, salt, fat, and a LOT of sugar. It’s basically a miniature dessert disguised as a candy bar.
Sauternes, the sweet wine from Bordeaux, brings honeyed fruit, stone fruit, tropical fruit, richness, and acidity.
That acidity is important because it keeps the pairing from becoming overwhelmingly sweet. The wine’s sweetness is also high enough to stand up to the candy. A very dry wine alongside a Snickers would be harsh and thin by comparison.
Then there’s the peanut and caramel combination. The nutty and caramelized flavors in the candy find plenty of compatible flavors in the wine.
Not a Sauternes fan? Try a late-harvest Riesling. You get the same basic formula: sweetness to match the candy and acidity to keep things fresh, but with more citrus and stone fruit flavors.
Candy Corn
I think candy corn might be one of the most polarizing Halloween candies. People seem to either love it or hate it.
Candy corn is almost all sugar, with a soft, waxy texture and flavors of vanilla and honey. There isn’t much acidity, salt, bitterness, or fat to provide another dimension.
And that makes Prosecco an interesting partner.
The acidity and bubbles provide a much-needed contrast to all that sugar. The wine’s fruit and floral aromas also complement the candy’s sweet, vanilla-like character.
I’d go with an “extra dry” Prosecco if you’re looking for a slightly more harmonious pairing. Despite the name, Extra Dry Prosecco contains more residual sugar than Brut. That extra bit of sweetness makes it better equipped to stand up to the candy corn.
If you prefer contrast, go with Brut. The drier wine and bubbles will make the candy seem even sweeter while refreshing your palate.
The alternative? Opt for a sparkling Moscato. It will be sweeter and more fruity, turning the combination into something closer to a dessert.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
These are my favorite, whether paired with wine or not. And my choice to pair with them is Amontillado Sherry.
And get those images of Grandma with her little glass of sherry out of your head. Sherry is one of the most diverse wine categories in the world, and I’m betting it will be making a comeback very soon.
Reese’s combines milk chocolate, sugar, salt, and rich, fatty peanut butter. Amontillado brings aromas and flavors of toasted nuts, hazelnuts, dried fruit, and baking spices, along with a dry, savory flavor.
The key is the nut/nut connection.
The roasted peanut flavor in the peanut butter cup finds a natural partner in the toasted nutty character of Amontillado. The wine’s dryness also provides some contrast to the sweetness of the candy.
Plus there’s some interesting science behind the mouthfeel here. Research has shown that fats can interact with wine tannins and influence the perception of astringency. While Amontillado isn’t a tannic red wine, the broader lesson is useful: the fat in food can substantially change how we experience wine.
What’s the alternative? While Amontillado Sherry is a more interesting and sophisticated pairing, Tawny Port will give you a more immediate delicious pairing because it brings much of the same characteristics, including nutty flavor, but adds more sweetness for a richer, more decadent combination.
Skittles
If you’re going to put Skittles and wine together, you need to embrace what Skittles are: intensely sweet, intensely fruity, and surprisingly tart.
That’s why I would reach for an off-dry Riesling because it has something Skittles desperately need in a wine: acidity.
The wine’s residual sugar keeps it from tasting thin or sour next to the candy, while its acidity provides a refreshing counterpoint to all that sugar. Its citrus, peach, apple, and floral flavors also reinforce the candy’s fruit flavors.
This is a good example of a pairing based on both similarity and contrast. The fruit flavors complement each other while the wine’s acidity cuts through the candy’s sweetness.
And here’s a useful pairing rule to remember. When you’re pairing wine with something very sweet, the wine generally needs enough sweetness of its own to keep it from tasting harsh or flat.
The alternative: Try a Moscato d’Asti. It will be even sweeter, lower in alcohol, and slightly fizzy, making it a particularly fun pairing with Skittles.
M&M’s
M&M’s are essentially milk chocolate wrapped in a crunchy sugar shell. Compared with Snickers or Reese’s, they’re relatively simple.
That’s why I’d choose Gamay, particularly a Beaujolais, which brings strawberry, raspberry, and cherry flavors, and plenty of freshness and relatively little tannin.
And that last part matters.
Tannin creates the drying, mouth-puckering sensation we associate with many red wines. Research shows that tannins interact with proteins and other components in the mouth to produce that sensation.
Very sweet candy isn’t necessarily the best partner for a heavily tannic wine. The combination can make the wine seem harsher, more bitter, and more drying.
Gamay avoids that problem. Instead, you get juicy red-fruit flavors alongside the chocolate with enough acidity to keep the combination lively.
The alternative? Reach for a light-bodied Pinot Noir. Look for one with bright fruit and moderate tannin (perhaps one from New Zealand) rather than a heavier oak-driven style.
The Real Lesson
The interesting thing about these pairings isn’t really the wines themselves. It’s the reason why they work.
- Snickers and Sauternes: sweetness, acidity, caramel, and nuts come together
- Candy Corn and Prosecco: bubbles and acidity contrast with intense sweetness
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and Amontillado Sherry: nutty flavors connect with the dry wine contrasts with the candy’s sweetness
- Skittles and Riesling: fruit and sweetness complement each other while acidity provides balance
- M&M’s and Gamay: bright fruit and low tannin are less likely to be overwhelmed by the candy’s sweetness.
Of course, there’s one final problem with all of this.
You might have children who come home on Halloween with a bag full of candy. You might have every intention of teaching them about sharing. You might even tell them that you’re going to take “just one piece.”
But let’s be honest. You’re an adult. You bought the wine. You did the research. You’ve carefully considered the interaction between sweetness, acidity, tannin, and fat.
You’ve earned that Snickers!
So either raid your kids’ trick-or-treat haul after they’ve gone to bed, or better yet, skip the kids entirely and buy your own candy. I won’t judge.
Just remember to save me a Reese’s.
If you found this article helpful (or just plain fun) scroll down and subscribe. You’ll get the first notification, before everyone else, when a new article is published.






Leave a Reply