With the possible exception of a July 4th burgers and hot dogs cookout, Thanksgiving dinner is the most iconic American meal. Every family I know puts their own variations on the menu, but I’d bet most dinner tables this Thanksgiving will have at least a few of the traditional dishes: roasted turkey, stuffing, gravy, mashed and/or sweet potatoes, green bean casserole, cranberries, and dinner rolls. And don’t forget pumpkin or apple pie for dessert!

That’s a lot of different flavors and textures all in one meal. Think about it:

  • Turkey is rather mild in flavor.
  • Stuffing can be rich and savory, with lots of herbs and spices.
  • Gravy adds more richness and fat.
  • Mashed potatoes introduce creaminess, and sweet potatoes add (of course) sweetness.
  • The cream of mushroom soup and fried onions in the green bean casserole bring umami flavor, while cranberries are tart.
  • Pumpkin pie and apple pie add more sweetness.

All of these flavors and textures can make choosing wine difficult. But it doesn’t have to be.

What makes a good Thanksgiving wine?

There are certain characteristics wines should have to pair well with the dishes on your Thanksgiving table. The goal is, with all the different foods, to not find a technically perfect pairing for one dish, but rather one that is versatile and flexible to go with the whole meal.

So we should consider:

  • Acidity: Wines with crisp acidity help cut through rich foods like gravy, mashed potatoes, and creamy casseroles.
  • Body: Medium-bodied wines generally work better than very light-bodied or heavily-structured wines because they can hold their own with a variety of dishes without overpowering or being overpowered by the food.
  • Tannins: Highly tannic wines can overwhelm the turkey and other more delicate dishes. Softer, more approachable red wines will fare better.
  • Fruits and Flavors: Wines with brighter fruit characteristics can complement the combination of savory, sweet, umami, and tart flavors.

Best White Wines for Thanksgiving

White wines are great choices for the Thanksgiving dinner table, especially when they’ve got enough fresh acidity and flavor. My recommendations are:

Riesling: Riesling is a very versatile food wine and will complement the combination of savory and sweet flavors, and its acidity works beautifully with roasted turkey, stuffing, and rich side dishes. Remember, Riesling can come in a variety of styles from very dry to very sweet. I would choose an off-dry Riesling with a hint of sweetness to go well with dishes sweet potatoes, glazed carrots, and cranberries.

Chardonnay: Here’s where you could go with a couple different Chardonnay styles if you prefer a fuller-bodied white wine. An unoaked or lightly oaked Chardonnay will pair well with the turkey and lighter side dishes while a more heavily oaked version will complement creamy, buttery mashed potatoes and gravy.

Viognier: This is for those who might want to serve something a little different. Viognier is a more aromatic wine with a fuller-body that goes with roasted turkey and savory dishes. And if you’re focusing on American-made wine, look at Viogniers from Virginia, where it does particularly well.

Best Red Wines for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is an occasion where lighter to medium-bodied, lower tannin wines outperform bolder, more robust red wines. I’d look for:

Pinot Noir: Pinot Noir fits the bill with its lighter to medium-body, bright acidity, low tannins, and red fruit flavors that complement roasted turkey, mushrooms, stuffing, and herbs. A Pinot Noir from California or Oregon will have a bit more fruit focus, while a Burgundy may have more earthy characteristics.

Gamay/Beaujolais: Gamay goes with Thanksgiving for all the same reasons as Pinot Noir. I would avoid Beaujolais Nouveau, which might be a little too light and overly fruity and instead reach for a Beaujolais Village or Cru.

Grenache: This is an option for those who prefer a fuller-bodied wine. Grenache typically won’t overpower the food because it has lower tannins, and it’s ripe red fruit flavors will go nicely with many Thanksgiving dishes.

Remember, wines that are more heavily tannic like Cabernet Sauvignon might overwhelm the food, especially if you’re serving turkey, but they aren’t forbidden. If you like them, drink them!

Don’t forget about bubbles!

Sparkling wines can go just as well with your Thanksgiving as the other wines I’ve recommended. They work well because they’ve got:

  • High acidity that refreshes the palate,
  • Bubbles to help balance rich and fatty foods,
  • A versatility to go with appetizers, turkey, and many side dishes.

And you don’t need to splurge on Champagne. Cava or an American sparkling wine works perfectly well.

And what about dessert?

I think that apple pie or pumpkin pie is the perfect way to end any meal. And a perfect accompaniment to either pie is Tawny Port. Tawny Port develops complex flavors, and depending on its age and style, you’ll often find notes of:

  • Dried figs and raisins
  • Toasted nuts
  • Caramel and toffee
  • Baking spices

Putting those together with baked apples and cinnamon or the ginger and cloves and rich creaminess of pumpkin makes for a delicious finish to the meal. I’d look for a 10-Year-old Tawny Port.

How much should you buy?

This is often a dilemma when planning any dinner party. You want to have enough so that you don’t run out, but not so much that you have a lot left over. For Thanksgiving, I tend to lean more towards having too much because the holiday season after Thanksgiving presents plenty of opportunities for sipping and sharing. Just make sure you’re doing what you can to make your open wine last longer and that you’re storing unopened bottles properly.

Keep in mind that a standard 750ml bottle of wine will pour roughly five 5-ounce glasses (which is a bit lighter than many of us actually pour at home.) I’d plan on about half a bottle per wine drinker for your Thanksgiving meal, and maybe more if you’re planning on serving wine before and/or after the meal.

Consider offering one red, one white, and one sparkling option, but if your guest list is small, I’d go with one red and one white. And if it’s just an intimate Thanksgiving meal for two of you, go with a bottle of white.

The Most Important Consideration

Thanksgiving is all about gathering with family and friends, enjoying a meal, counting our blessings, and creating memories. There’s no one perfect wine for the occasion, so you shouldn’t stress about your wine choice.

So feel free to experiment. Serve a wine that you enjoy. And remember that the best part of Thanksgiving dinner are the people gathered around the table and not what is on the table.

Happy Thanksgiving!

Leave a Reply

Trending